April_AMP_Digital

6 A D V A N C E D M A T E R I A L S & P R O C E S S E S | A P R I L 2 0 1 8 It was with keen interest that I read the “Feedback” letter from Chuck Do- hogne [January issue] sent in response to my co-authored article, “Copper Al- loys Resurface as an Antimicrobial Force” [October 2017]. I am pleased to respond with facts rather than resort to glib comments and misleading opin- ions, as this writer does. Dohogne states that copper “was very high tech—3500 years ago!” Copper is not a relic resid- ing only in the periodic table. Copper alloys continue to be widely used in large quantities in the modern era due to unique properties such as high elec- trical and thermal conductivity, corro- sion resistance, ease of fabrication, and their ability to kill bacteria and prevent hospital-acquired infections. He further states that copper al- loys “would make for lots of new jobs polishing all that brass.” However, a tar- nish-resistant copper-nickel alloy was used in the clinical trial. It is in the same family of alloys that coat the surfaces of U.S. coins (nickels, dimes, and quar- ters). These copper-nickel alloys do not normally tarnish and typically are not polished. Dohogne then cites my “recurring mention of 99% (reduction of live bac- teria in laboratory testing)” as mean- ing “absolutely nothing.” As an aside, the reduction in bacteria was only men- tioned once and it is 99.9% rather than 99%. More importantly, the writer ap- parently fails to appreciate that a near- ly two orders of magnitude reduction of infectious bacteria is significant and not trivial. It should be noted that cop- per alloys have the ability to keep kill- ing bacteria and protecting humans when the surface is re-contaminated, all without human intervention. He also states that, “Instead of stainless steel, the comparison should have been made with something that works, say titanium?” Note that stainless steel is mandated as the ex- perimental control ma- terial by the U.S. EPA and is widely used in mi- crobiology labs. Stain- less steel, like titanium, has no inherent ability to kill bacteria and thus neither “works.” Do- hogne goes on to say, “A bit of UV light and every- thing is gone, bacteria, viruses, mold spores, and biofilms.” The ox- ide that naturally forms on the surface of titani- um is titanium dioxide, a photocatalytic material. When titani- um is exposed to UV, it oxidizes and kills bacteria. Thus, the combination of ti- tanium surfaces and UV is antimicrobi- al. Titanium by itself has no antimicro- bial effect. More importantly, without UV, oxidized titanium surfaces are im- mediately re-contaminated after being touched with a contaminated glove or hand. UV light can be highly effective on all materials, including copper, even if they are not photocatalytic. However, in contrast to the combination of titani- um and UV, copper alloys keep reducing bacteria on a 24/7 basis without requir- ing hospital staff time. Dohogne further states that, “Ma- terials cost means nothing for medi- cal applications.” This may be true for surgical joint implants covered by in- surance. However, hospital adminis- trators are very conscious about the cost of components that come out of their budgets. In a multi-hospital clini- cal trial, six components made of cop- per alloys were placed in random pa- tient rooms. Although the copper alloy components comprised less than 10% of the surface area of the rooms, these components were the most frequently touched items. The trial continued until the results were deemed to be statisti- cally significant. A remarkable 58% re- duction in infection was achieved com- pared to infection rates measured in the control rooms—much better than “al- most nothing.” A multipronged approach is need- ed to fight hospital infections. It should include good hygienic and infection control practices—as well as new tech- nologies such as copper alloys and UV light—in order to achieve optimum re- sults. Sooner or later, most of us wind up in the hospital. If and when you are a patient, I hope that copper alloys are one of the tools used by your hospital to protect you from infections. They really work. Harold T. Michels ASM Life Member INFECTION-FIGHTING COPPER NOT A RELIC OF THE PAST FEEDBACK We welcome all comments and sugges- tions. Send letters to frances.richards@ asminternational.org. A typical patient room retrofitted with copper alloy compo- nents. Four of the six copper retrofits are visible, including the over-the-bed table, IV pole, data input device (touch screen bezel), and caps on the bed rails.

RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjA4MTAy