August_EDFA_Digital
edfas.org ELECTRONIC DEVICE FAILURE ANALYSIS | VOLUME 20 NO. 3 12 most complex part types and are more likely to be prime targets, due to the following reasons: • Less likely to have multiple manufacturers making pin-compatible parts • More likely to undergo frequent upgrades or revisions for faster, better parts • More likely to be considered critical components of a system The result is that the three most highly counterfeited IC part types are also more likely to cease production earlier—thus becoming obsolete—and be replaced by better versions. Once obsolete, in-production replace- ments are less likely tobe found fromcompetitors, leaving the systemdesigner facing the challenge of either finding out-of-production parts or redesigning the system to accept a new design. This is the perfect storm that forces a search of the graymarket where the counterfeit part risk soars. These parts o¨en list for many times the standard price, maximizing profit. Analysis of recent data shows a decreasing trend in IC percentage, accompanied by an increasing trend in transistors and capacitors. Figure 3 shows the part-type breakdown for 2017, confirming this trend. Data for 2018 is updated through March 17. Because the 2018 snapshot reflects less than a quarter of the year, it is not conclu- sive. However, it should be noted that both rising trends (transistors and capacitors) have been present since the fourth quarter of 2017. For example, there have been more suspect capacitor reports (45) in the six months from September 2017 through March 2018 than in the two years prior (43). It appears from the data presented that counterfeit- ers may be delving into more counterfeiting of lower complexity parts, including discrete semiconductors and passive components. A DEEPER LOOK AT CAPACITORS The trending counterfeit capacitor phenomenon can be brokendown further into capacitor types (e.g., ceramic, tantalum, aluminumelectrolytic, film, etc.). Figure 4 shows this trend from 2012 through mid-March 2018. As indicated here, the increase in capacitor reporting is almost exclusively due to ceramic capacitors. On the surface, this is counterintuitive, because ceramic capaci- tors are typically among the cheapest electronic parts, o¨en selling for pennies. On the other hand, tantalum and aluminumelectrolytic capacitors sell for 10 times this priceormore.While theseparts, alongwith film, porcelain, andother specialty capacitors are also counterfeited, their percentages are much lower. Why? A review of the part numbers, reports, and a little analysis of ceramic capaci- tor design reveals the reason why counterfeiting of these parts is profitable. First, ceramic capacitors are small. With length and width typically down to a tenth of an inch or less, there is seldom room for marking the parts. Therefore, a counter- feiter need not worry about removingmarkings, recoating parts, and adding new markings. Second, there is great variation in capacitance value, voltage, and tolerancewithin the same size package. Low value, low voltage, or high tolerance parts can be pack- aged and labeled as if they are high value, high voltage, or low tolerance parts, thus increasing their value. There is virtually no dierence in the physical size of these parts, except perhaps a slight variation in thickness. (continued on page 14) Fig. 3 Suspect counterfeit percentage by part type. Fig. 4 Suspect counterfeit percentage by capacitor type.
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjA4MTAy