August_EDFA_Digital
edfas.org ELECTRONIC DEVICE FAILURE ANALYSIS | VOLUME 20 NO. 3 10 RECENT TRENDS IN COUNTERFEIT ELECTRONIC PARTS Fred Schipp Naval Surface Warfare Center, Crane, Ind. frederick.schipp@navy.mil EDFAAO (2018) 3:10-16 1537-0755/$19.00 ©ASM International ® C ounterfeit electronic parts have been the scourge of the electronics industry for more than a decade. In fact, reports of suspect counterfeit parts can be found in Government-Industry Data Exchange Program (GIDEP) database reports as early as the 1970s. Since the turn of this century, counterfeiting of electronic parts seems to have reached epidemic proportions. ERAI, 1 a member-based organization that tracks reports for suspect counterfeit parts, has averaged nearly 100 reports per month for more than five years, although that trend appears to be decreasing. This count, although high, is assumed to be just a fraction of the true counterfeit- ing total. It is diicult to assess the true impact of counterfeit electronic parts. Themost common counterfeit part actu- ally has the correct internal die, so it functions correctly in the circuit. The problem is that the part may have been tested toa slower specificationor toa smaller temperature range (e.g., commercial instead of industrial). Another major concern is that the part has likely seen prior use, followedby removal and refurbishment under undesirable circumstances. This handling and refurbishment creates a significant risk of mechanical (cracks and breaks), elec- trical (electrostatic discharge), chemical (corrosion), or thermal (delamination and die voids) damage. These examples all contribute to yielding a part that, despite passing initial testing, may be a ticking time bomb—partially damaged or unsuitable for the applica- tion, and perhaps likely to fail at a critical time. This article does not seek to determine the system impact of counterfeit electronic parts nor does it address intentionally modified, malicious counterfeits, or even cloned devices. Instead, it provides data in order to esti- mate the actual extent of counterfeiting, analyzes data to identify recent trends in counterfeiting certain part types, and assesses the current value of authentication methods. Most of this information applies to standard “vanilla” counterfeits. These are parts assumed to have been modified to allow the counterfeiter to profit. EXTENT OF THE PROBLEM The best place to assess the extent of the problem is through analysis of ERAI data. ERAI is a paid member- ship organization that has been logging suspect coun- terfeit and high-risk parts at least since 2005. The parts reported in ERAI are not all suspect counterfeit, but most are thought to be so. This data suggests a continuous increase inmonthly reports, plateauing at approximately 95 monthly reports for a nearly five-year span from 2011 through 2015. However, the same data indicates a steady reduction in monthly reports for the past two years or more (see Fig. 1). Why the downward trend? The optimist might con- clude this is due to several reasons, while the pessimist may have completely dierent theories regarding the downward trend. Beloware a fewoptimistic explanations for the reduction since 2015: • Fewer parts are being counterfeited because it is too tough to make a profit. • More counterfeit parts are being caught at the U.S. border and are not making their way to reporting companies. • Fewer counterfeit parts are being purchased due to increased awareness and obsolescencemanagement. 1 ERAI Inc. is a global information services organization that monitors, investigates, and reports issues aecting the global electronics supply chain. Members include aerospace, defense, medical, nuclear, and commercial OEMs, CMs, OCMs, distributors, government agencies, industry associations, and other organizations serving the industry.
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjA4MTAy