May_EDFA_Digital
edfas.org ELECTRONIC DEVICE FAILURE ANALYSIS | VOLUME 20 NO. 2 4 EDFAAO (2018) 2:4-8 1537-0755/$19.00 ©ASM International ® FAILURE MECHANISMS OF ELECTROMECHANICAL RELAYS ON PCBAs: PART II Gert Vogel, Siemens AG, Digital Factory Division, Control Products, DF CP QM SQA 5 gert.vogel@siemens.com INTRODUCTION Many printed circuit board assemblies (PCBAs) not only have electronic components, but also electrome- chanical relays. The spectrum of root causes that lead to an increased contact resistance or a complete contact failure of these relays is completely different than failures of electronic components. A detailed analysis of some typical failures and the corresponding root causes are presented in this article. Part I of this article (February 2018 EDFA ) explained that many of the failure mechanisms that lead to contact failures of electromechanical relays are actually self-cen- tering effects. Nonconducting silicon dioxide forms in the contact region out of silicon vapor or silicon oil, due to the fact that electric arcs only occur at the shortest distances between two contacts. As a result, the failuremechanism is self-centering. SiO 2 only formswhere it can cause a fault. The nonconductive plastic particle between two con- tacts is not positioned there by accident, but as a result of adriving force—a self-centering effect that results fromthe vibrationofmechanical switching and the force of an inho- mogeneous electrical field, which occur simultaneously. Countermeasures in the form of a thin contact oil film prevent particles from bouncing, but can also lead to a newself-centered failuremechanism—as stickingparticles migrate into the contact region along the oily surfaces of the contacts. The driving force of this effect is the surface tension of the oil film, which wants to minimize itself and therefore contracts in the capillary around the contact point. When the contacts open, particles on the oil film are pulled in the direction of the contact area. Particles in the contact region result in an elevated contact resistance if two conditions aremet: Theymust be large enough to keep the contacts permanently apart, yet small enough that an electric arc can occur. Oxidation of the surface, and sometimes evenmaterial migration, can cause this increased resistance. Once again, the mecha- nism is only self-centering at the contact point. ARCING AND FORMATION OF NITROUS OXIDES Particles between two switching contacts do not always result in contact failure. If the applied voltage is high enough, the distance between contacts can be bridged by an arc. Small particles usually burn, leaving only a slight discoloration on the contact surface. If arcing occursmore frequently and acutely, e.g., due to increasing wear and abrasion between the contacts, then contacts may fail—or the contact resistance may increase. However, arcs canalsohave unexpected effects: Arcing causes nitrous oxides (NO x ) to be formed from the oxygen and nitrogen in the air. In combination with moisture in the relay, nitrous acid, respectively nitric acid, is formed. For example, a fluttering relay can produce such a high amount of nitrous gases due to a defective capacitor that serious corrosion can occur in a sealed relay (Fig. 1). The actual cause, however, is the defective capacitor. PHOSPHORUS DEPOSITS ON RELAY CONTACTS An accumulation of noxious gases from arcing in an Fig. 1 Due to contact “flutter,” arcs occur over a long period of time, leading to the accumulation of nitrogen oxides in sealed relays. In conjunctionwithmoisture, nitrous acid is formed, enabling significant corrosion.
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjA4MTAy