February_EDFA_Digital
edfas.org ELECTRONIC DEVICE FAILURE ANALYSIS | VOLUME 20 NO. 1 A SUMMARY OF THE ISTFA 2017 PANEL DISCUSSION: STRIVING FOR 100%SUCCESS RATE Susan X. Li* and Renee Parente,** ISTFA 2017 Panel Discussion Organizers *Cypress Semiconductor Corporation, San Jose, Calif. — susan.li@cypress.com **Advanced Micro Devices, Austin, Texas — renee.parente@amd.com EDFAAO (2018) 1:S1-S6 1537-0755/$19.00 ©ASM International ® D uring ISTFA 2017, we successfully hosted a Panel Discussionon the topic of “Striving for 100%Success Rate.” The failure analysis (FA) community knows that achieving 100% success rate is the ultimate goal for FA operations, and it holds particular importance for indus- tries, such as automotive, aerospace, and oil companies, beyond the traditional semiconductor chipmakers. Five area experts among these industries shared their views on our panel regarding what “100% success rate” means to their organization, what challenges they encounter when working toward this goal, and the experiences they have in their daily work when operating toward this goal. Dr. David Su, a director of the FA group at TSMC, Taiwan, began the Panel Discussion. David shared with the audience his belief that every sample is important, because finding the cause for failures is critical for fab process improvement. In the wafer fab foundry, a challenge can be the lack of sufficient product knowledge; therefore, it is particularly important to have strong partnerships with requesters in order to make the FA successful for root-cause finding. David emphasized the importance of a strong, experienced, expert team that is disciplined yet thinks outside the box and is fast but meticulous. He also cautioned that quickly finding a physical defect could lead to early, misguided satisfaction in the FA process, so be sure the analysis continues until the true root cause of the issue is found. Our second presenter, Mr. Dan Bodoh, a technical director in the Product Diagnostic Center at NXP, focused mainly on electrical FA and fault isolation for new product introduction (NPI). Dan indicated the importance of having a definition of “failure analysis success.” NXP uses three criteria for successful FA: (1) conclusive evidence that connects electrical behaviors to a physical defect, or (2) a fingerprint or a signature is already agreed upon, or (3), for early NPI debug, significant contribution to the product and design team’s understanding of an issue. Dan shared the belief that FA leadership has a responsibility to keep an eye on the processes in the lab, because it is okay tomake a mistake, but patterns of mistakes must be investigated, as it is critical to learn fromthem. He also encouraged holding “challenging analysis meetings” to brainstorm with the team, and building a team led by experienced people not bound by the daily cycle-time pressure but empowered to help the team have better productivity and quality daily analysis work. Unlike the first two speakers fromthe traditional semiconduc- tor wafer fab and chipmakers, our next three invited speakers were from companies in special application areas. Dr. Oliver Senftleben, a senior technical expert from Audi Semiconductor Lab in Germany, shined light on the automakers’ perspective of 100%FA success rate. For auto- makers, 100%success rate is a requirement, not a strategic goal. On average, there are 6000 to 8000 semiconductors in each car; therefore, a 1 ppm random failure rate means 10,000 to15,000defects in car components, basedon yearly production volume for Audi. A 100%success rate is impera- tive for qualification failures, because findings impact new vehicle project releases. A typical qualification sample size is six devices; thus, failures could likely imply systematic issues. Rapid determination of countermeasures, even based just on the failure symptoms, is critical for 0 km fail- ures, because potential systematic failures are pushed into the field every 80 s per production line. Quick root-cause identification of field failures is a priority, because system- atic and epidemic failures lead to high warranty costs and “FIVE AREA EXPERTS AMONG THESE INDUSTRIES SHARED THEIR VIEWS ON OUR PANEL REGARDING WHAT “100%SUCCESS RATE” MEANS TO THEIR ORGANIZATION...” S - 1
Made with FlippingBook
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjA4MTAy